Top 5 Items That Bring the Highest Cash Offers at Jewelry Buying Events
Every National Rarities buying event is full of surprises. Guests bring in everything from heirloom rings to vintage handbags, and often walk away amazed at the offers they receive. While nearly any fine jewelry or valuable collectible can hold worth, some categories consistently bring the strongest cash offers.
If you’re wondering what jewelry sells for the most and which items to bring to an event, here are five that stand out.
1. Diamond Jewelry
Diamonds never go out of demand, and their value often comes down to the famous “4 Cs”: cut, clarity, color, and carat weight. Whether it’s a single loose stone, a diamond engagement ring, or a vintage necklace, these pieces are among the most sought-after. Many guests who sell diamond jewelry at our events are surprised to find out that even older or out-of-style settings can still fetch significant offers thanks to the stone itself.
2. Gold Coins
Coins made from gold and silver remain one of the most popular categories at buying events. U.S. gold coins such as the American Eagle or historic Liberty Head coins often command high interest. International coins, like South African Krugerrands or Canadian Maple Leafs, also perform well. The condition of the coin matters, but even well-worn examples can bring in competitive offers when you sell gold coins.
3. Luxury Watches
Certain watches hold their value — and in some cases, appreciate over time. Rolex, Omega, Cartier, and Patek Philippe are among the top brands that consistently receive strong offers. If you’re looking to sell a Rolex watch, you’ll likely see one of the highest payouts at a jewelry buying event. Even vintage or non-working watches may have significant value because of their craftsmanship and materials.
4. Estate and Designer Jewelry
Beyond diamonds, unique estate jewelry and pieces from well-known designers also bring impressive cash offers. Think of iconic names like Tiffany & Co., David Yurman, or Van Cleef & Arpels. Collectors and buyers prize these items not only for their materials but also for their artistry and heritage.
5. Sterling Silver Flatware and Serving Pieces
It might surprise some guests, but sterling silver flatware, tea sets, and serving trays remain strong performers at buying events. Many families inherit these items and keep them tucked away for years. If it’s marked “Sterling” and not plated, chances are it holds real value.
Ready to Sell?
Bringing the right items to a National Rarities buying event can mean walking away with significant cash offers the same day. From diamond jewelry to gold coins and luxury watches, the market demand for these valuables remains strong nationwide.
Curious if your items qualify? Explore our upcoming events and see when National Rarities will be in your area — it may be the perfect opportunity to find out just how much your treasures are worth.